Choosing Between Hearing Aids and Cochlear Implants

Profile of a man wearing behind the ear hearing aids

How do hearing aids work?

Hearing aids are small electronic devices that are worn in or behind the ear. They amplify sounds and make them easier to hear for individuals with mild to moderate hearing loss. They come in a variety of styles and are made of three parts that all work together to allow you to hear:

 

A microphone receives sound and converts it into digital signals

An amplifier increases the strength of the digital signals

● A speaker produces the amplified sound into the ear 

 

Hearing aids pros

  • Hear sounds you haven’t heard previously
  • Hear speech over the phone more clearly. Many modern hearing aids come with Bluetooth connectivity, which means you can directly stream calls from your phone to your hearing aids. 
  • Improved ease in listening environments. When you first wear hearing aids, you will notice sounds that may seem annoying. However, your ability to tune them out will improve as your brain adjusts to hearing softer sounds. 
  • Less interference from background noise. Hearing aids with directional microphones will focus on the person speaking, making it easier to tune out the background noise.
  • Communicate with people more easily. Communicating and participating in social situations decreases your risk of social isolation, depression, and cognitive decline associated with untreated hearing loss. 

Hearing aids cons

  • Hearing aid feedback. This occurs when the sound that was supposed to go into your ear canal leaves your ear and jumps back into the hearing aid microphone. This causes a whistling noise and can be very annoying for wearers.
  • Clogged with wax. Certain types of hearing aids that are placed in the ear can get blocked with earwax, preventing sounds from entering your ear. 
  • Maintenance. They require regular maintenance and may need to be replaced every few years.
  • They may not help. If you have severe to profound hearing loss, hearing aids might not help, which is where cochlear implants come in. 

Costs considerations

The cost of hearing aids can vary depending on the type, style, and features. They can range from a few hundred dollars to several thousand dollars per ear.

While some insurance plans cover hearing aids, many do not, and out-of-pocket costs can be a significant barrier for some people.

However, there are also programs and resources available to help make hearing aids more affordable, such as Medicaid, Medicare, and nonprofit organizations.

How does a cochlear implant work?

Cochlear implants have been a game-changer for individuals with severe hearing loss, offering a chance to regain some level of hearing ability.

Like hearing aids, they can’t restore normal hearing. However, unlike hearing aids, they pick up sound and send it straight to the hearing nerve via the cochlea. 

What are cochlear implants?

Cochlear implants are electronic devices that are surgically implanted into the inner ear. They work by bypassing the damaged parts of the ear and directly stimulating the auditory nerve.

Cochlear implants are typically recommended for individuals with severe to profound hearing loss who do not benefit from hearing aids.

There are three main types of cochlear implants: 

  • Single-channel implants use a single electrode to stimulate the auditory nerve
  • Multi-channel implants use multiple electrodes to provide more precise stimulation
  • Hybrid implants combine the benefits of both single-channel and multi-channel implants, using both types of electrodes to provide optimal hearing ability.

How does a cochlear implant enable hearing?

These medical devices consist of two main components: 

  • an external processor
  • an internal implant that is surgically implanted in the inner ear

The external processor captures sound and converts it into digital signals, which are then transmitted to the internal implant.

The implant then stimulates the auditory nerve, allowing the brain to perceive sound.

Cochlear implant pros and cons

One of the primary advantages of cochlear implants is that they can significantly improve an individual's quality of life.

Research has shown that cochlear implants can improve speech perception, communication abilities, and overall social functioning.

Additionally, cochlear implants can help individuals with hearing loss better enjoy music and other auditory experiences.

However, there are also some potential disadvantages to consider.

Cochlear implants require surgery, which comes with inherent risks. Additionally, the devices may not work for everyone, and there is a learning curve associated with adjusting to the new sounds and sensations provided by the implant.

Finally, cost can be a significant consideration, as cochlear implants can be expensive and may not be covered by insurance.

It is important to note that cochlear implants are not a "cure" for hearing loss, but rather a tool to help individuals better navigate their hearing loss.

As with any medical decision, it is important to carefully consider all factors and consult with a medical professional to determine the best course of action.

Despite the potential risks and costs, cochlear implants remain a valuable option for individuals with severe hearing loss who do not benefit from traditional hearing aids.

Invisible cochlear implants

An invisible cochlear implant functions via a receiver-stimulator system and sound processor that are implanted through surgery and completely hidden.

Essentially, these are fully implantable auditory aids with the speech processor, battery, and microphone residing beneath the skin, rendering the device not visible.

A woman with a yellow shirt perfoming a hearing test
Take care of your hearing health now!

Schedule a free hearing consultation in the nearest store.

Book your appointment

Cochlear implants vs hearing aids

So, what’s the difference between cochlear implants and hearing aids?

They both have their unique advantages and disadvantages, and it is crucial to understand their differences to make an informed decision about which one is right for you.

Cost

The cost is one of the most significant differences between hearing aids and cochlear implants.

Hearing aids are generally less expensive, ranging from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars.

Cochlear implants, on the other hand, can cost tens of thousands of dollars, making them a much more significant financial investment.

However, it is important to consider that many insurance plans, including Medicare, cover the cost of cochlear implants for those who meet certain criteria.

Additionally, cochlear implant manufacturers often offer financing options to help make the cost more manageable.

Effictiveness

When it comes to effectiveness, both hearing aids and cochlear implants can be very effective in improving hearing.

However, cochlear implants are generally considered to be more effective for those with severe to profound hearing loss, while hearing aids are often more effective for those with mild to moderate hearing loss.

Studies have shown that cochlear implants can significantly improve speech recognition and sound localization in those with severe to profound hearing loss, while hearing aids may not provide enough amplification for those with more severe hearing loss.

Convenience

In terms of convenience, hearing aids are generally considered to be more convenient than cochlear implants.

Hearing aids are small and discreet, and can easily be removed and reinserted as needed.

Cochlear implants, on the other hand, require surgery to implant the device, and cannot be easily removed or reinserted.

Maintenance

It is important to consider that cochlear implants do not require daily maintenance like hearing aids do.

Hearing aids require regular cleaning and battery replacement, while cochlear implants only require occasional maintenance appointments with a healthcare provider.

It is important to note that both hearing aids and cochlear implants require regular use to maintain their effectiveness.

Those who do not use their devices regularly may experience a decline in their hearing abilities over time.

Lifestyle considerations

When considering which device is right for you, it is essential to consider your lifestyle and daily activities.

For example, those who enjoy swimming or other water activities may find that hearing aids are not suitable for their needs, as they can be damaged by water.

Cochlear implants, on the other hand, are waterproof and can be worn during water activities.

Additionally, those who work in noisy environments may find that cochlear implants are more effective at blocking out background noise than hearing aids.

User satisfaction

Overall, both hearing aids and cochlear implants have high levels of user satisfaction.

However, studies have shown that those who receive cochlear implants often report higher levels of satisfaction than those who use hearing aids.

This may be due to the fact that cochlear implants are generally more effective for those with severe to profound hearing loss, and can provide a greater improvement in hearing abilities.

Suitability for different types of hearing loss

Finally, it is important to consider the type of hearing loss you are experiencing when deciding between a hearing aid and a cochlear implant.

Hearing aids are generally more effective for those with mild to moderate hearing loss, while cochlear implants are more effective for those with severe to profound hearing loss.

Additionally, those with certain types of hearing loss, such as single-sided deafness or mixed hearing loss, may find that a cochlear implant is a more effective solution than a hearing aid.

Factors to consider

1. Age

 

Age plays a crucial role in determining the best option between hearing aids and cochlear implants.

For children with severe to profound hearing loss, cochlear implants are often recommended as they provide better speech and language development.

However, for adults with mild to moderate hearing loss, hearing aids may be a more suitable option.

2. Lifestyle

 

Lifestyle is an essential factor to consider when choosing between hearing aids and cochlear implants.

For individuals who lead an active lifestyle, such as athletes or musicians, hearing aids may be a better option as they are less intrusive and do not require surgery.

On the other hand, cochlear implants may be a more suitable option for individuals who work in noisy environments or have difficulty understanding speech even with hearing aids.

3. Personal Preference

 

Personal preference is an important factor to consider when choosing between hearing aids and cochlear implants.

Some individuals may prefer hearing aids as they are less intrusive and do not require surgery, while others may prefer cochlear implants as they provide better speech understanding in noisy environments.

4. Communication Needs

 

For individuals who rely heavily on speech communication, such as teachers or public speakers, cochlear implants may be a better option as they provide better speech understanding in noisy environments.

However, for individuals who primarily communicate through sign language, hearing aids may be a more suitable option.

Profile of an elderly man with a black background
5. Degree of Hearing Loss

The degree of hearing loss is another critical factor to consider.

Hearing aids are typically recommended for individuals with mild to moderate hearing loss, while cochlear implants are recommended for those with severe to profound hearing loss.

Hearing Loss Types

6. Consultation with an audiologist

Consultation with an audiologist is crucial when choosing between hearing aids and cochlear implants.

An audiologist can help determine the degree of hearing loss, lifestyle, communication needs, and personal preference to recommend the best option.

They can also provide information on the latest technology and advancements in hearing aids and cochlear implants.

7. Insurance coverage

Insurance coverage is an important consideration when choosing between hearing aids and cochlear implants. While most insurance plans cover hearing aids, coverage for cochlear implants may vary.

It is essential to check with your insurance provider to determine the coverage for both options.

8. Cost consideration

Cost considerations are another crucial factor to consider when choosing between hearing aids and cochlear implants.

Hearing aids are typically less expensive than cochlear implants, but they also need to be replaced more frequently.

Cochlear implants are more expensive upfront but may last longer and require less maintenance in the long run.

How to clean and maintain hearing aids or cochlear implants

Like any other electronic device, hearing aids and cochlear implants require proper maintenance and care to function correctly.

Neglecting to care for these devices can lead to malfunctions, costly repairs, and even permanent damage. Proper maintenance and care are crucial for their longevity and effectiveness.

How to take care of you devices

  1. Clean your hearing aids or cochlear implants daily: Use a dry, soft cloth to wipe down the device and remove any earwax or debris. Avoid using water or cleaning solutions, as they can damage the device.
  2. Replace the batteries regularly: Low batteries can cause the device to malfunction or stop working altogether. Check the battery level often and replace them as needed.
  3. Store your hearing aids or cochlear implants in a safe place: When not in use, keep your devices in a dry, cool place, away from extreme temperatures and moisture. Store them in a protective case to prevent damage.
  4. Schedule regular maintenance appointments: It's essential to have your hearing aids or cochlear implants checked and cleaned by a professional regularly. They can detect any issues and make necessary adjustments to ensure the device is working correctly.

Common mistakes to avoid

  1. Using water or cleaning solutions: Water and cleaning solutions can damage the device. Avoid using them to clean your hearing aids or cochlear implants.
  2. Not replacing batteries regularly: Low batteries can cause the device to malfunction or stop working altogether. Check the battery level often and replace them as needed.
  3. Not storing the device properly: Storing your hearing aids or cochlear implants in a damp or hot environment can damage the device. Always store them in a dry, cool place, away from extreme temperatures and moisture.

Recent advancements in hearing loss solutions

Latest hearing aid: characteristics & benefits

Hearing aids have undergone significant improvements in terms of technology and design. The latest hearing aids are smaller, more discreet, and more powerful than ever before.

They come with advanced features such as noise reduction, directional microphones, and Bluetooth connectivity, which allow users to stream audio directly from their smartphones or other devices.

Additionally, some hearing aids come with rechargeable batteries, eliminating the need for frequent battery replacements. The latest hearing aids can provide better sound quality, reduce background noise, and improve speech understanding in noisy environments.

They also come with wireless connectivity, which allows users to stream audio directly from their smartphones or other devices, making it easier to communicate with others.

Additionally, some hearing aids can be customized to fit the user's specific hearing needs, providing a more personalized hearing experience.

Latest cochlear implants: devices & technology

Cochlear implants have also undergone significant advancements in recent years. The latest cochlear implants come with multiple electrodes that can stimulate different parts of the auditory nerve, providing more precise and natural sound perception.

Additionally, new surgical techniques have made it possible to implant cochlear devices in individuals with more severe hearing loss. These advancements have expanded the pool of eligible candidates for cochlear implants, allowing more individuals to benefit from this technology.

Cochlear implants can provide a more natural sound perception, improve speech understanding, and enhance the ability to localize sounds.

They can also improve the quality of life for individuals with hearing loss by allowing them to participate in social activities and communicate with others more effectively.

Cochlear implants can benefit individuals with severe to profound hearing loss who are not able to benefit from hearing aids.

Latest hearing loss developments: gene therapy

Researchers are exploring the use of gene therapy to repair or regenerate damaged hair cells in the inner ear, which are responsible for converting sound waves into electrical signals that the brain can interpret.

While this technology is still in the early stages of development, it has the potential to provide a permanent solution for individuals with hearing loss.

The advancements in cochlear implant technology and gene therapy have the potential to significantly improve the lives of individuals with hearing loss.

Cochlear implants can provide a sense of sound to individuals who were previously unable to hear, allowing them to communicate more effectively and participate more fully in social situations. Gene therapy has the potential to provide a permanent solution for individuals with hearing loss, eliminating the need for hearing aids or other devices.

While the advancements in hearing loss solutions are promising, there are still challenges and limitations that need to be addressed.

Cochlear implants require surgery and are not suitable for all individuals with hearing loss. Gene therapy is still in the early stages of development and may not be a viable option for all types of hearing loss. Additionally, the cost of these treatments may be prohibitive for some individuals.

Profile of an elderly man with a hat
Are you eligible for cochlear implants?

The criteria for candidacy may vary depending on the individual and their specific needs, but generally, individuals must have a severe or profound sensorineural hearing loss in both ears and have a functioning auditory nerve

With you on your journey to better hearing.

It's time to finally treat your hearing loss. Sign up for a free consultation with a licensed hearing care professional today to determine if you have hearing loss. It’s the start of your journey towards better hearing.

EarPros benefits:

  • It's 100% risk free
  • Best partner with more than 1.000 stores

Please use a valid US zipcode.

Please use a valid zipcode.

Thank you for submitting your request

We will get in touch with you as soon as possible.
Veterans and hearing loss

Learn more about hearing loss

Get to know hearing loss better on our blog.

Schedule a free hearing aid consultation